You Don't Want a Unicorn by Ame Dyckman
We love You Don't Want a Unicorn because it is hilarious. The unicorns poop cupcakes. While disgusting, it's also hilarious. Too many unicorns together decide to have a party and that can cause all kinds of damage. We probably read this book at least 3x/week before bed. It's a real party pleaser.
A Unicorn Named Sparkle by Amy Young
We love how much Sparkle does not look and act like a 'real' unicorn. Lucy has high hopes for the unicorn she orders, but is disappointed when Sparkle arrives. She calls the unicorn man to come and take Sparkle back because he doesn't act like a real unicorn.
Not Quite Narwhal by Jessie Sima
I love this book. Love. Love. Love. Kelp doesn't know if he really belongs with the narwhals or with the unicorns. A great story about finding yourself and accepting who you really are.